This liner applies easily with a good eyeliner brush. It has intense depth and satisfying color payoff. It reads as true navy without turning brown or black on me. I found it very easy to pack on the brush. You can do either a defined line with wing or a more all-over lid for a really vampy look. It's an absolutely stunning eyeliner!

I love the eyeliners here. I live by them. I don’t even wear makeup anymore except for art stuff, but I will never let myself run out of the red eyeliner.

The blue on the other hand… it’s fine. I know blue pigments are difficult to work with, especially in makeup, so I should have expected the final product to be less forgiving than the other shades… but this one has a much drier touch and finish, and it leads to a lot of tearing (for me). Once I start tearing up, the blue eyeliner runs right off. It’s probably good if you don’t have sensitive eyes, but I think the amount of pigment needed to make this blue really pop just doesn’t work with my eyes and my skin. Maybe you’ll be different! Hopefully the future formula for the blue shades will be gentler without sacrificing the saturation 🤞

This is my first Black Orb eyeliner (Dusk) and based on other reviews it may be different than the others but it does require some work. You have to work the brush in the pot back and forth before you can get a good solid amount on the brush to apply without being patchy. It may be the kohl that makes it seem dry at first? Once it's on it's pretty but it doesn't last all day. I just don't know if I like this formula and would buy again.