When I first bought them, I thought for sure that Abyss would be my go-to color with Cinder begging for attention in the corner. Not so. I am absolutely in love with this color. It has a slate grey color. Very blue toned while remaining distinctly grey. This is generally my everyday eyeliner. It creates smoke and fog It is quiet drama without the intensity of Abyss. It creates definition without calling attention to itself. Abyss is a star. Cinder is a wallflower.

When it comes to eyeliner, specifically, I like deep, dark pigments. This is a beautiful color, but for me, it's not deep enough for a liner. I'd use it more as a shadow to do a smoky gray, although it might be too intense for me as an eye shadow. But, it was a great introduction to this formula and I think I might for for Dusk and Iron, maybe even Abyss, though their longevity isn't great. I feel like one accidental eye scratch and I'm a goner. I suffer from trichotillomania, so I need eyeliners that last for eternity until I deeply massage off with a thick oil cleanser. These would be great for days when I haven't suffered an episode, but when I do, I need me that heavy duty liquid liner that sits on the lid all day. I am hoping RdF comes out with more liner products, be it eye pencils that are clean and long lasting, and/or liquid liners.